The Stages of Reductionism

· Metacrisis, People

What do Hannah Arendt and Nora Bateson have in common?

In Combining, Nora Bateson writes about different aspects of reductionism:

FRAGMENTATION

Looking at something complex, and dividing it into parts.
i.e. splitting a tree into the roots, trunk, branches, leaves…

SEPARATION

Disconnecting those parts from each other.
i.e. chopping through the trunk, breaking the branches off the trunk, pulling the leaves off the branches…

OBJECTIFICATION

Taking those parts, and removing them from their original context.
i.e. the trunk becomes floorboards [or a home for bugs], the branches become a fence [or a dog toy], the leaves become a trip hazard on the pavement [or something to kick up and play with on your way to school]…

It’s not necessarily a linear process, one step to the next, neither is it necessarily a bad thing. Reducing complexity can help us understand things more easily - it’s hard to understand ‘the ocean’ all in one go, but if we start with trying to understand a glass of water, things can be a little more manageable.

There is danger, however, when we try to over-simplify and deny the complexity - which brings me back to Hannah Arendt.

In The Origins of Totalitarianism, she writes that a deliberate tactic of totalitarian propaganda is to de-humanise specific elements of society. This intentional objectification was crucial in enabling many of the horrors associated with the Second World War.

And we see echoes of this now. On multiple levels - political, ethnic, species, etc - we continue to separate ourselves from ‘the other’ … often with devastating effects.

The problem with this fragmentation is that it doesn’t make the complexity go away. It’s still there, lurking in the background … waiting to knock us over…

The response is to face - and name - the shadow of separation. To see ourselves as a collectively entangled mess…

Who - or what - do I objectify?

Who - or what - do I see as ‘the other’?